Ingredients
4tsp active dry yeast (I think this is about 2 packets, but I don't use packets)
1/4 cup honey (I usually add just a bit more than that, like 3/8)
pinch of salt (1-2tsp)
2.5 cups of water (115 degrees ish)
6-ish cups of flour (3 white bread flour, 3 wheat flour or just all white bread)
Variant 1 - doesn't last as long (2-3 weeks in the fridge) but the flavor is better and fluffier texture
2tbs butter (fresher is better) + more for pans/bowls
1 egg (room temperature is preferable)
Variant 2 - lasts longer (3-4 weeks in the fridge) still yummy but not quite as much so
1/4 cup vegetable oil
Other Variants
- 6tbs butter
- 2tbs butter 1/4 cup vegetable oil
Step 1 - Brown Your Butter
If using butter, browning it first adds some wonderful flavor to the bread. Put your butter in a sauce pan put the pan over medium heat. Once your butter is all liquidy just sit there and swirl the pan on the burner, changing directions occasionally (or wisk/stir it if you prefer). Don't you dare leave though or your butter will pop, splatter, or burn. This requires constant stiring/swirling until the butter starts to get brown flakes in it.. then go a little longer until the brown flakes make the butter look browner. Once it's browned, remove from the heat and let it cool down. We want it to be a liquid but we don't want it to kill our yeast, which it will do if it's too hot.
Step 2 - Proof Your Yeast
This is important so you don't waste as much if your yeast is bad (or water too hot/cold) but has no real impact on the bread itself if everything is good. Put the warm water in a bowl (if you have a stand mixer, put it in that bowl), stir in the yeast, wait 5 minutes. If the yeast starts to foam/bubble then you're good to continue.
Note: I add honey at this stage as well to give the yeast something more to eat but honey is expensive and it's not necessary to see the proofing work.
Step 3 - Rough Dough
Dissolve the honey and salt in the yeast and water then wisk in the egg. Alternate 1/2 a cup of each flour type mixing it in reasonably well between each. It doesn't need to be super smooth, some chunks are ok at this point. Do this till you've added 4-5 cups of flour, or until it becomes difficult to mix with a spoon. Once at that point turn it out onto a lightly floured counter/surface. It may still be fairly sticky at this point, I just flour my hands generously to pull it all out with minimal stickage.
Step 4 - Kneeding
This is the hardest step (physically) cause it must be done by hand. If you're using a stand mixer then you can probably get the rough dough a lot further than if you're hand mixing and that will save your arms some. Slowly add the remaining cup or so of flour and kneed it into the dough. The final dough should be tacky but not sticky. If you're not sure what that means, let it sit on the counter for a few seconds and then try to lift it up from the sides, if much stays stuck to the counter then you need to continue adding flour and kneeding. You should be able to squeeze the dough with an un-floured hand and not have dough stick to it when you pull it away (it will stick and pull a little but none should remain on your hand after pulling away).
roughly:
5-10min after a stand mixer
15-20min after hand mixing.
Step 5 - First Rise
Butter a large bowl, at least twice as large as your dough ball. Place your dough ball into the bowl, swish it around a little and then flip it over and swish it again. We want butter to cover the dough ball on all sides. Cover with a damp towel or plastic wrap and set in a warm place, such as the top of your fridge. Alternatively leave it uncovered and microwave half a cup of water for two minutes then place the dough in the microwave with the steaming cup of water. Now go do something else for 45min to and hour but don't forget about your dough!
Step 6 - Second Kneed - Form the Dough
Your dough ball should have roughly doubled in size by now, if not then let it rise longer.. though you may also want to check on it at the 30min mark or so. We don't want it to over-rise too much on that first rise either. Plop the dough ball out onto a lightly floured surface and kneed for another 5 minutes. The goal of this kneeding is to get all of the large air pockets out of the dough without tearing it. Basically kneed until it stops making poping and hissing noises at you. Butter your loaf/cooking pan. Rip the dough in half, if you're making a loaf then take one (or each) half and flatten it to be roughly as long as the bottom of your loaf pan and about three times as wide. Fold the dough in thirds and place in the buttered pan. If you're making rolls and such then shape into what ever you want the shape to be really, but roughly 1/3-1/2 the size you want it to end up as. I usually do 1 loaf and 1 pan of hotdog, hamburder, and sandwich buns/rolls.
Step 7 - Second Rise
Pre-heat your oven to 350 degrees, it needs to be ready for the dough when ever the dough is done rising. Do the same trick with the microwave (or just put it ontop of your fridge) and let the dough rise again, for another hour or so or until proper size. It will rise slightly more in the oven but not much so just put it in when you like the size of your dough.
Step 8 - Baking
This is the hardest part technically speaking, over or under cooking is really easy to do (I've done both unfortunately!). It's difficult to tell whether your bread is done or not, it can look perfectly golden brown on the top and be either burnt on the bottom or raw in the middle :(. So this may take a few tries to get your timing down as every oven is different.
At this point your dough looks like un-cooked whatever it is that you're making! We're close but don't eat it just yet. Don't even touch it or look at it funny, it's pretty delicate at this point and even light pressure will leave an indent in the final product. Rolls/buns/smaller things need to cook for about 15-20 minutes while a full loaf is going to need 30. Rotate your pans at the half way mark to ensure even cooking.
Step 9 - Patience Please
You have bread!! and as tempting as it is to cut into it and enjoy the wonderful warmth you must restrain yourself. Rolls and smaller things are ok to cut and eat almost right away but your loaf must cool before you cut it open. If you don't then you can end up with deflated breadand that's just sad. The loaf must cool and harden before you can cut it. Don't let it cool over-night though, or you might have stale breadinstead. Give it an hour or two on your counter (prop it up against something like a cutting board so the bottom has air flow, or use a proper cooling wrack..). Then it can go into a plastic bag and into your fridge.
Step 10 - Making it Last Longer
Honey is a natural preservative, even if you leave it out (in a bag, like store bread) it should last 1-2 weeks before growing mold but I don't eat it quite that fast. I'll put it in a plastic bag and store in my fridge, whenever I eat it I just microwave my portion for a few seconds or toast it briefly to warm it back up. Eggs and butter are what the mold likes to eat and grow on though, so using the oil variant will make it last even longer yet and is still quite tasty